dinkydave

Sonus Faber Concertino Speakers

38 posts in this topic

Since getting back from this year's Scalford show I have just not been able to get over how good the Sonus Faber Guarneri Homage speakers sounded in amcluesent's room. Now I know that the rest of amcluesent set-up probably contributed to the excellent sound alot, but I tend to be in the camp of speakers are the most important thing. Now I love my ProAc D1 speakers, and to me the Sonus Faber Guarneri Homage speakers were in the same ball-park sound style wise, they just did it much better :^. So, I have been checking the usual places to see about trying / buying a pair of these and they are not cheap :(. Most I would go to is £1500 and the only pair I have seen were at £1790. So, I have pretty much given up on owning a pair of these, but there are alternative Sonus Faber speakers about and I have been looking at one on ebay - a Sonus Faber Concertino Speaker. Reviews are good, but then again all reviews tend to be good :roll:.

So, has any one got any experience of these speakers?

To be honest, unless anyone comes on and tells me these are totally crap, I am probably going to buy some, compare to my ProAc D1s, probably end up disappointed and send them straight back to e-bay (expect I'll end up losing 50 - 100 quid on the deal).

Just thought I would ask first :).

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't know much about them, apart from them being quite pretty. Here's a pair with stands for sale. No connection with seller.

http://www.hifi-forsale.co.uk/moreinfo.php?prod_title=sonus_faber_concertino__home_and_stands&p=speaker&prod_id=4394&offset=0

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Don't know much about them, apart from them being quite pretty. Here's a pair with stands for sale. No connection with seller.

http://www.hifi-forsale.co.uk/moreinfo.php?prod_title=sonus_faber_concertino__home_and_stands&p=speaker&prod_id=4394&offset=0

Cheers for the link :^

These are a set which are up for sale on ebay, either that or there is a big coincidence with the location. Don't really need another set of stands and Nottingham is too far to drive.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Concertinos are pretty good. But better than your Proacs? Not sure....

Yes, I think I could end up being dissapointed :?.

Should say that if anyone can suggest an alternative in my price bracket (would ideally like it to be a Sonus Faber ......) please do so. Must be pretty small mind you.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Concertino is not at the Guarneri Homage's level. The D1 should sound more detailed, refined and have superior imaging than the Concertino, though the latter would perhaps sound more lush, warm and musical due to the lack of high frequency extension and detail.

I have owned the Sonus Faber Grand Piano Concerto before and listened to the Concertino's bigger brother, the Concerto. They all share a pretty similar family house sound.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Before I forget, the Guarneri Homage is touted as the most neutral(and best) bookshelf in the SF line. Check out the Stereophile review, the reviewer preferred the Guarneri Homage over the Extrema for its true-to-the-source delivery.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Dave,

I owned a mark one set of concertinos with matching stands for about 5 years . Criminally I used them for rear channel duties in an all S-F HT setup. If I had realised how good they were I would have bought 2 pairs instead of the Grand Pianos which I used for the front speakers.

The Concertinos were easier to drive and match and unless the Grand Pianos were hooked to really powerful amps, the difference in real bass output was surprisingly little and certainly not enough to justify the almost 2.5x price difference. Build quality is exemplary and they are super high on WAF. I had the piano black models and they looked gorgeous.

However the piano finish is harder to touch up if dinged (as I found out when a Grand piano tipped gently against a nearby glass shelf :-()

The Concertinos don't require lots of power but need a clean sweet amp. I tried more amps with the Grand Piano in particular and Concertino (which is less fussy) than all my other speakers put together. The best amp I heard was Sonus Faber's own Musica and the Sugden A21a. Lots of dealers sell them with Coplands which didn't gel to my ears. The krell KAV 300 integrated was also popular, but I thought the beefier sounding KAV500 was better suited.

However they are probably a step sideways compared to your Pro-Acs. All other things being equal, the S-Fs will sound a little warmer and woolier, but your amp choice will probably dictate which sounds nicer.

If you scratch the itch, I would recommend you seek out a pair with the matching stands, they are great and the speaker actually bolts to the top plate, so are very secure. They are built to withstand a nuclear attack and very non resonant. They are also usefully taller than regular stands which helps the speaker to fill the room.

BTW. All my comments apply to mark 1 concertinos. I am not sure which ones you are looking at but the ones on Hifi for sale are mark Twos. The spider over the tweeter is the easiest giveaway. I personally preferred the Mark Ones to the mark Twos. The mark ones are a little richer, the mark twos are a bit cleaner. The mark ones should also be cheaper.

I hope this may assist,

Graham.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Concertino is not at the Guarneri Homage's level. The D1 should sound more detailed, refined and have superior imaging than the Concertino, though the latter would perhaps sound more lush, warm and musical due to the lack of high frequency extension and detail.

I've got a set of Townshend Supertweeters which might help out a bit in this respect, but your comments about the imaging do give me cause for concern :?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Proac speakers have always been one of the best in imaging. I've owned the Tablette 50 Signatures and their imaging is excellent and superior to the Sonus Fabers. Though I have to admit my 3 years experience is with the Grand Piano Concerto and not the Concertino. Graham may be in a better position to advise on the SF Concertino vs Proac D1 although I suppose the Grand Pianos sound very similar to the Concertino.

When I had the Grand Pianos I tried many amps to make them work. They sound too warm, wooly and lacklustre when paired with equally warm and/or smooth sounding amps. They need quite a bit of current to get going as well. I find the Krell KAV-300i to be the best match in injecting some life and dynamics to the Grand Piano.

Generally the Sonus Faber Concertino will sound warmer and less accurate than the D1, less detail and woolier. Graham's impression mirrored mine as well. A dynamic amp like the Krell can ameliorate things, though you can only go so far..

I agree it is a sideway move going from the D1 to the Concertino.

Good luck.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi Dave,

BTW. All my comments apply to mark 1 concertinos. I am not sure which ones you are looking at but the ones on Hifi for sale are mark Twos. The spider over the tweeter is the easiest giveaway. I personally preferred the Mark Ones to the mark Twos. The mark ones are a little richer, the mark twos are a bit cleaner. The mark ones should also be cheaper.

I hope this may assist,

Graham.

The ones I am looking at do not have the grills, so I guess that makes them the mark ones. Get the feeling the one I am looking at are over priced as they are £550 without the stands. Beinging to feel like a re-think is comming on :?.

Cheers for all the info :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

£550 without the stands? .... they were £600 brand new, and if they are mk1 then they are probably over 10 years old. £300 would be more like it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name=ryder;1229649

When I had the Grand Pianos I tried many amps to make them work. They sound too warm' date=' wooly and lacklustre when paired with equally warm and/or smooth sounding amps. They need quite a bit of current to get going as well. I find the Krell KAV-300i to be the best match in injecting some life and dynamics to the Grand Piano.

Generally the Sonus Faber Concertino will sound warmer and less accurate than the D1, less detail and woolier. Graham's impression mirrored mine as well. A dynamic amp like the Krell can ameliorate things, though you can only go so far..

.[/quote]

Yes ryder has got it spot on. I tried so many amps with the Grand Pianos and never really found one to hit the spot, except for S-F own design which on paper had nothing special to commend it or justify the high price (or the questionable aesthetics) for that matter.

As ryder says, a Krell 300 is probably the no brainer amp. But I was surprised at how well the Sugden (which I bought for very different speakers) powered the bigger brother grand pianos. However as mentioned the Concertinos were much less fussy and realistically 95% as good. I much preferred the Concertinos to the Concertos which always sounded a bit slow to my ears.

Personally, although the Concertino is a decent speaker (and good value compared to the Concerto and Grand Piano) I would stick with the Pro-acs. I am not familiar with the D1, but I prefer the 1SC and the D2 to these 'entry level' Sonus Faber range.

It might be more fun spending some of the money you have just saved yourself on getting a solution for the TT "in the loft" :-)

All the best, Graham.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
£550 without the stands? .... they were £600 brand new, and if they are mk1 then they are probably over 10 years old. £300 would be more like it.

Yes, just notice a pair sold on here 6 months ago for £300. Will not be buying the ones off e-bay now.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've got SF Concertinos on 'ironwood' stands too....I use them with a Quad 34/306 combo, actually prefer them to SF Concertos which I found too smooth and lacked sparkle.

Comparison to the Guarneris? Bit like an Audi A4 to an A6, it's much the same but just on a smaller scale.

I paid £3500 for the Guarneris with the original stands, although I took the 'ironwoods' to Scalford as the Guarneri stands must be getting on for 50kg each.

cf83856f.jpg

P.S. gad you liked the setup at Scalford

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.