Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
SSM

Naim Nait XS

40 posts in this topic

I hear this new Naim(£1250) has only just premiered in Blighty. This is going to be much too hopeful... but has anyone heard it already in comparison with the Nait 5i? I'm wondering how much of a lift in performance it will offer over the Nait 5i? 60W vs 50W doesn't seem like an overwhelming increase in power.:? If nay, the 5i seems better value for money.

The 'X' moniker is very desirable though. Magic letter.:D

SS

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't heard it but performance will be that of the Supernait. i.e between the 112/150 and 205/200.

From what I understand its a Supernait without the Dac,

Regards

PB

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hmm...:geek: given the SuperNait's RRP, the value of that onboard DAC is £1100 then.:P

The XS definitely appears better value than the SuperNait IMO. Not reached the shores of Tipoca yet. Perhaps its worth the patience of waiting another four weeks or so to hear it before committing to the Nait 5i.:?

Ta.

SS

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Solid - what speakers did you hear the 5i's with? Iwill demosome Naim kit if I ever have any upgrade dosh. The Naim stuff I have heard has been through Naim speakers or those horrible rectangular box things at the last Heathrow show, they have never done it for me yet.

I know for sure that I don'tto loose the Prattyness of the Evo's though.

Cheers BB

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How would you guys rate the Nait 5s' and 5is'?

Im asking as i have a Nait, the old school original and i love its sound, really engaging and a slight amount of warmth and lots of clarity. I heard that the later Naits lost this signature naim sound, but without hearing its impossible to tell.

So how do the Naits compare through the ages?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BB, the Naits were hooked to Wharfedale Opus 2-1 and the way the Nait 5i gripped those drivers...:^:shock:

Richard Black's first review of the EVOs said Creek is a "poor man's Naim". While I'd disagreed with that tongue-in-cheek comment (the EVO amp has its own non-Naim charms), it may be obvious that Creek modeled the EVO amp after the first Nait 5i. They have the same energetic delivery.

So you definitely won't be missing any PRaT if you switch to Naim someday, BB. I reckon the new Naits will suit you to a T.:)

cheerSS

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Burnibus wrote:

How would you guys rate the Nait 5s' and 5is'?

Im asking as i have a Nait, the old school original and i love its sound, really engaging and a slight amount of warmth and lots of clarity. I heard that the later Naits lost this signature naim sound, but without hearing its impossible to tell.

So how do the Naits compare through the ages?

The previous Nait 5i didn't impress me with classical music. It sounded crumbly and chunky with the sample music I tried.

The new Nait 5i cooks with classical stuff. I was shocked.:shock: It presented an alternative, yet valid presentation to my MF X-T100. The X-T100 places emphasis on spatial depth and tonal smoothness (classic MF traits), the Nait 5i holds a magnifying glass over the minutiae of instrumental tones: the rosin on strings, quivering vibrato... it's more busy sounding than the MF, yet it remains cohesive and very life-like.

And of course, there is the inimitable timingTM.:D

SS

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Solid,

I wouldn't place too much store in the power rating of Naim amps. My 250 only measures at 75W but packs a weighty punch.

Like PB I can't comment on the sound of the XS but would be worth your while waiting for a listen. IncidentallyI heard the Supernait in a high quality vinyl systemlast weekend and it was very good.

Strat

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So true, Strat.:) The "flea-powered" amps from the big boys often prove to be much more powerful in practice. My 50W MF throws out a bigger soundstage than CA's 120W Azur 840A.:D

NB: The old Nait 5i is more than 50W. It measured 65W/105W (8/4 ohms) in HFN(May 06)specs.gifwith peaks of 75W/125W/200W into 8/4/2 ohms. Tested with Dali Ikon 6, which is what I have.:love:

I just don't like the idea of owning two amps both rated at 50W...:P

I've calmed down after the euphoria of hearing the Naits. This time I'll take it slow and spend the rest of Dec checking out other new stuff from other brands. Hope to catch Roksan's 125W Kandy K2 in action sometime next week. Nice looks and I really like candy.licker.gif

cheerSS

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Roksan amps are really good as well - the aesthetics aren't as smart as Naim imo but from my albeit limited listening they really give a fullsome sound.

One other thing - a lot of nonsense (positive and negative) is written about Naim equipment but the biggest myth is that it doesn't play classical. This is simply rubbish - our system is sublime with the old stuff.

Strat

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a Nait XS arriving at Beobloke Towers next week, amongst a few other amps, so I'm looking forward to seeing how well it compares to the Supernait. A Kandy K2 has also been here for a few weeks now and I do like it, but it's not quite perfect - I'd personally still plump for the Nait 5i over it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SSM wrote:

Burnibus wrote:
How would you guys rate the Nait 5s' and 5is'?

Im asking as i have a Nait, the old school original and i love its sound, really engaging and a slight amount of warmth and lots of clarity. I heard that the later Naits lost this signature naim sound, but without hearing its impossible to tell.

So how do the Naits compare through the ages?

The previous Nait 5i didn't impress me with classical music. It sounded crumbly and chunky with the sample music I tried.

The new Nait 5i cooks with classical stuff. I was shocked.:shock: It presented an alternative, yet valid presentation to my MF X-T100. The X-T100 places emphasis on spatial depth and tonal smoothness (classic MF traits), the Nait 5i holds a magnifying glass over the minutiae of instrumental tones: the rosin on strings, quivering vibrato... it's more busy sounding than the MF, yet it remains cohesive and very life-like.

And of course, there is the inimitable timingTM.:D

SS

I'd be quite surprised if either the new XS or the Nait 5i "cooks with classical stuff". The Naim sound is fundamentally wrong for classical music with that emphasis on the bass and something missing in the treble. While Naim amps always make a great initial impression and are amazing for rock, they don't have the right balance for classical music IMHO.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I beg to differ sir, earlier Olive series and its emphysis on the leading edge wasn't the best for classical music but the more balanced reference series plays classical music rather well.

Saying that I recall sitting in a Spanish Villa in the Summer with Frank F and one of the most Naim, Naim systems an active SBL system. You would be hard pushed to claim it wasn't ideal for classical music. It was very good and very real,

Regards

PB

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I knew someone was going to come to their defense about this. I used to have a Nait 5i and thought it was great (despite the annoying humming and buzzing and ludicrous snap crackle and pop when switched on). Then one day a musician friend came over and pointed out this imbalance while we were listening to St Matthews Passion. I hadn't noticed it before, but once it was pointed out it was unmistakable. The friend had never heard a Naim amp before and had none of the usual preconceptions about the brand. Someone else later said to me, and I think this is another reason why Naim amps don't work well for classical music, that the Naim sound is like sitting in the front row when what you really want for classical music is a seat in the middle of the orchestra.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.